American Idol 10 Top 13 Performances & Result 

Banyak yang bilang bakat tahun ini melebihi bakat-bakat yang berkompetisi di musim-musim sebelumnya. Dan awal putaran final ini akan membuktikannya. Seperti yang Simon selalu bilang, “It’s either make you or break you”. Dengan tema idola para peserta, inilah American Idol.

Lauren Alaina – “Any Man of Mine” by Shania Twain – producer Don Was
ST: “Gotta have a good song, I wished it had been more kick ass”
JL: “We want you to kick it into high gear. Now it’s time.”
RJ: “That’s a cool song, you sang it well…we want to see something that makes you shine beyond belief.”
AI: Sejak Kellie Pickler sukses menyegarkan suasana American Idol dengan kepribadiannya yang lugu, beberapa kontestan muncul dengan ide serupa. Tahun lalu kita punya Siobhan dan tahun ini Lauren Alaina. Kesimpulan singkat mengenai penampilannya minggu ini: KARAOKE. (5/10)

Casey Abrams – “With A Little Help From My Friends” by Joe Cocker – producer – Jimmy Iovine
JL: “At one point I grabbed Randy and said what am I watching? Blew me away.”
RJ: “Dude, you were so unbelievable and so exciting. You make listening to you sing fun.”
ST: “You are a rainbow of talent, man. You are a plethora of passion. Everyone in the house felt what you did. Yowza.”
AI: It was great! Selain link ke Joe Cocker, dia seperti versi muda-nya Taylor Hicks. Dia punya koneksi yang terbangun dengan sangat kokoh pada penonton. (9/10)

Ashthon Jones – “When You Tell Me That You Love Me” by Diana Ross – producer Rodney Jerkins
RJ: “I liked it. It sounded like a safe move, but I liked it. You grew as a singer. You did yourself some good with that.”
ST: “There’s more in there than you’re showing us.”
JL: “You’re so elegant up there. But, I want to start seeing you sing songs that we can sing along with you. I think you are amazing.”
AI: Jika kalian butuh saran untuk membuat sebuah lagu indah menjadi sesuatu yang sangat terkesan sampah, tanya kepada Ashton Jones dan versinya untuk ‘When You Tell Me That You Love Me’. Setelah mendengar pendapat juri, aku benar-benar merindukan sosok Simon yang akan dengan tega menyatakan bahwa penampilan tersebut “rubbish”. Ada yang setuju kalau suara Ashton aneh? (4/10)

Paul McDonald – “Come Pick Me Up” by Ryan Adams – Producer Don Was
ST: “I love the character and the rasp in your voice. A little pitchy. Nail it next time.”
JL: “You’re so unique. You moved the crowd. I hope America gets it. I don’t know Ryan Adams and that song.”
RJ: “After last week’s performance, it wasn’t the most exciting thing. I love the character. I get it I hope America gets it.”
AI: Setiap kali setelah melihat penampilan Paul, hanya akan ada 2 feedback; LOVE IT atau HATE IT. Dan aku berada pada barisan LOVE IT! Lupakan pitchy dan yang lainnya, I LOVE HIS PERFORMANCE! (8/10)

Pia Toscano – “All By Myself” by Celine Dion – producer Ron Fair
JL: She thinks Pia topped last week “Really beautiful.”
RJ: “We say don’t tackle those songs if you can’t do them. But you have that quality. You hit the notes dead on without even thinking about it. Very hot dope cool performance.”
ST: “That was the sum of all your performances so far.” He wishes Pia a happy International Women’s Day. “You just polished that apple. You just slammed it. That was beautiful.”
AI: Kalau Amerika memilihnya sebagai pemenang American Idol, acara ini akan memiliki seorang diva pop. Mari bersorak sorai atas keberhasilannya menyanyikan ‘All By myself’ versi Celine Dion! Dua jempol. (9/10)

James Durbin – “Maybe I’m Amazed” by Paul McCartney – producer Jim Jonsin
RJ: “You’re one of my favs in this whole thing. I love this kind of voice. Now you come out and sing Paul McCartney and slayed it. You showed you had a sensitive side. Dude. James Durbin is dangerous, America.”
ST: “You have taken everything you’ve ever felt and kicked it into next week.”
JL: “You have such a quality. You have what the greatest rock singers have. You’re melodic.”
AI: Akan semakin banyak orang yang percaya dan mengidolakan James Durbin setelah penampilannya ini. We’re all amazed kog, James! (9/10)

Haley Reinhart – “Blue” by LeAnn Rimes – producer Rock Mafia duo
ST: “That was beautiful. You can hear the rest of the country roaring. You did such a good job.”
JL: “I think America is really getting to know you now. You do really special things. It’s so unique to you. Really special.”
RJ: “I like that you can do anything. But it was a little sleep and a little boring.”
AI: Akui saja, Randy. Dirimu enggak suka sama Haley Reinhart. I LOVE HER PERFORMANCE THIS WEEK! Sama seperti yang Jimmy Iovine bilang, enggak sembarang orang bisa nyanyi lagu ini. I love the song, I love LeAnn Rimes, and I love her performance! (9/10)

Jacob Lusk – “I Believe I Can Fly” by R. Kelly – producer Rodney Jerkins
ST: “Pure passion, pure music, I can’t even judge it.”
JL: “You make us feel so much when you sing. It’s anybody’s game. You’re at the top of the list.”
RJ: “When you start, you have such a signature sound. You kinda went sharp, but by the end, you hit those high notes. I’m excited every time you hit the stage.
AI: Baiklah, ini mungkin akan jadi komentar yang kasar. Aku suka lagunya, aku suka aransemennya yang modern. Hanya saja, jeritannya semakin lama semakin mengerikan. Personal taste. Semoga American Idol tidak menjadi mimpi buruk. (6/10)

Thia Megia – “Smile” by Michael Jackson (his version) – producer Ron Fair
RJ: “I loved the intro, it was so beautiful, I heard Michael, a little Adele. All in all it was good. I loved the beginning more than the end.”
ST: “I got to agree. A little pitchy in the middle there. But you’re so young. Overall I liked it.”
JL: “The beginning reminded me a little bit of last week. I thought the arrangement was interesting. Doesn’t matter, you sing like an angel.”
AI: Coba lihat gaunnya, seperti yang dipakai sama New Directions di sectionals musim 2 Glee. Bagian pertama jauh lebih enak didengar dari bagian kedua. Penampilan Thia Megia seperti odong-odong, if you know what I mean. (5/10)

Stefano Langone – “Lately” by Stevie Wonder – producer – Polow Da Don
ST: “You pulled it off. It was like a volcano. Arrangement was crazy.”
JL: “You had me dancing there for a minute. It wasn’t just a copy of it it was really you.”
RJ: “It started off a little rocky for me. Stevie is so hard to sing. He’d be proud. You slayed it. Very nicely done.”
AI: Kalau saja ini lagu tidak populer, dengan aransemen demikian mungkin banyak yang akan menyangka ini adalah lagu Donna Summer. I like it, but don’t love it. (8/10)

Karen Rodriguez – “I Could Fall In Love” by Selena – producer Jim Jonsin
JL: “For me, I could tell you were a little uncomfortable with the notes. You’re one of our strongest girls, I hope you make it to next week.”
RJ: “It felt like you were fighting the song. It was a little sleepy for me. It didn’t quite come off for me.”
ST: “It was lacking a little bit. I know you can sing so much better.”
AI: Ya ampun Karen, sadarilah dirimu adalah salah satu favoritku tahun ini. Tapi menonton penampilan ini sedikit banyak menyiksa. (6/10)

Scott McCreery – “The River” by Garth Brooks – producer Don Was
RJ: “If it ain’t broke, don’t even think about fixing it. That’s a great Garth Brooks song. Dude, this is exactly where you belong. Don’t change it. I love it.”
ST: “You did the Garth justice. You’re riding high tonight.”
JL: “I saw you open up as a performer. You embraced the audience…your taking the audience on the ride with you. Congratulations.”
AI: Enggak ada komentar mengenai vokalnya, karena memang YGD; ya gitu dech. Kita lihat aja sejauh mana vokal YGD itu membawanya di American Idol ini. Kalau mau mencari yang beda dari Scotty McCreery, fokus pada cara tangannya memegang mic. (8/10)

Naima Adedapo – “Umbrella” by Rihanna – producer Tricky Stewart (produced the original)
ST: “You’re crazy good. A little pitchy. You brought flavor tonight. I adore you for that.”
JL: “You got fire girl. You dancing up there. You’re doing it the way stars do it. You need to work on the control. I’m glad you came out and id what you did.”
RJ: “I differ with Jennifer. I care about the pitchiness. You’ve got to have the breath and the control. The cutoffs were a little rough. I loved the whole reggae thing.”
AI: Naima is on fire! Satu dua tiga dan seterusnya nada yang melenceng, dimaklumi. Tapi ini penampilan terpanas minggu ini. (9/10)

Saatnya prediksi. Melihat ke depan, agak susah untuk menentukan siapa yang akan ada di 3 terbawah, kecuali Ashton Jones. Karena dia pantas tersisih juga minggu jadi. Dan yang bisa jadi ada disana bersamanya adalah Karen Rodriguez, Paul McDonald, dan Haley Reinhart.

The Result
Bottom 3: Karen Rodriguez, Ashthon Jones, Haley Reinhart

dan yang pulang adalah: Ashthon Jones

(Ai Hasibuan / CreativeDisc Contributors)