Trending News

Blog Post

American Idol 9 Top 3
American Idol

American Idol 9 Top 3 

Tak terasa American Idol 9 tahun ini yang sangat tidak menarik ini tersisa 3 kontestan yaitu Casey James, Lee DeWyze dan Crystal Bowersox. Beberapa shocking elimination dan juga judge’s save sudah kita lewati, tentunya dengan berbagai macam kekecewaan seperti yang kita baca di komen2 sebelumnya dan juga twitter2 semua org yg melihat American Idol 9 ini. Bukti nyatanya adalah tidak ada satupun single yang direlease oleh finalis American Idol 9 ini yang masuk di iTunes Top 100 Singles Chart maupun Billboard! But, The Show Must Go On! Dengan segala macam ketidakpuasan, kita harus mencari sang Idola terbaru! Siapakah yang berhak maju ke babak Final American Idol 9 minggu depan ini? Simak penampilan Top 3 minggu ini yang masing2 bakal membawakan 2 lagu, satu pilihan pribadi dan satu lagi pilihan para juri! Komentar (R) Randy Jackson, (E) Ellen DeGeneres, (K) Kara DioGuardi, (S) Simon Cowell, dan (CD) CreativeDisc.

ROUND 1 – Personal Choice


1. Casey James – “Ok, It’s Alright With Me by Erich Hutchinson”
(R) That was just alright for me. I needed to hear something unique and not safe. It didn’t quite work for me.
(E) This is the moment. I wish you would have brought it.
(K) It’s hard to pick something that no one really knows. That didn’t work in your favor.
(S) If you were having dinner that was the salad. That will have no lasting affect on the audience. A dud song choice.
(CD) Pilihan lagu yang tidak terkenal itu bisa jadi bumerang buat Casey apabila tidak dibawakan dengan baik, dan ini terbukti, Casey sudah menunjukkan betapa membosankan penampilan dia kali ini. (6/10)


2. Crystal Bowersox – “Come To My Window by Mellisa Etheridge”
(R) I did not love the arrangement. I did love your vocal on it though. You rose above the arrangement. It all worked in the end.
(E) It was a good song choice. It is the artist you want to be.
(K) I think you got a little lost in the arrangement but it was still a good vocal. I just hope you have a moment tonight.
(S) This isn’t the most stunning version of the song we are going to hear but you haven’t compromised yourself as an artist. I think you made the right choice.
(CD) Pilihan lagunya emang sesuai dengan Crystal yaitu sang Idolanya, Mellisa Etheridge yang sepertinya mereka bakal duet di Final nanti. Penampilannya kali ini So Crystal! (8/10)


3. Lee DeWyze – “Simple Man by Lynyrd Skynyrd”
(R) Brilliant song choice. You sounded amazing. Someone sounds like they could win this.
(E) That’s what we are talking about.
(K) What you did is what every contestant has to do. Round 1 goes to Lee.
(S) That song was absolutely on the money. You crushed Round 1.
(CD) Well, pemenang Ronde pertama ini jelas pasti dipegang oleh Lee! Dia kembali ke ‘akar’nya, dan sepertinya dia mix antara Kris Allen dan David Cook! Setuju? hehe (9/10)

Round 2: Judges Choice

4. Casey James: “Daughters by John Mayer” (Randy & Kara)
(R) This fits you like a glove and I hope you continue in this direction.
(E) I liked this and it was beautiful for you. I liked it a lot.
(K) This showed the more artist side of you. Good job.
(S) Much better song choice than the first one. It was a bit of a lazy song. I wish you had a much bigger vocal moment.
(CD) Pilihan yang bagus oleh para juri dilewatkan begitu saja oleh Casey. Walau penampilannya agak mendingan dari yang pertama tadi. Hmm, tiket pulang sudah didepan mata. (7/10)


5. Crystal Bowersox “Maybe I’m Amazed by Paul McCartney” (Ellen)
(R) Great song, great vocal. We got someone else in it to win it.
(E) I couldn’t have asked for more. You did it.
(K) You really showed parts of your voice we haven’t heard. You did a lot of risky things and I think it paid off.
(S) Now I get the song choice. You proved you got soul. After that you may be thanking Ellen for putting you in the finale.
(CD) Tampil tanpa gitar, agaknya membuat Crystal sedikit ‘kikuk’ di panggung. Tapi Vocalnya bener2 keren! (8/10)


6. Lee DeWyze “Hallelujah by Leonard Cohen” (Simon Cowell)
(R) This was your biggest moment. That was unbelievable.
(E) That was stunning.
(K) You are what this show is all about. You are the heart of the show this season and you just owned the entire night.
(S) You proved you are a fantastic singer and I hope you make it through.
(CD) Wow! Seperti melihat penampilan di Final, apalagi ditambah dengan ‘choir’ dibelakang Lee! Superb! Sepertinya kita sudah dapat jawaranya nih! (10/10)

So, siapa yang bakal kuar besok? Dan sepertinya kita sudah bisa menebak sejak Siobhan tereliminasi, dimana Lee vs Crystal di Final!
Tunggu Live Resultnya besok via twitter @creativedisc !

OFFICIAL RESULT: Casey James is out!
Final American Idol next Week: Lee DeWyze vs Crystal Bowersox!

Related posts

Leave a Reply