American Idol 9 Top 10 Boys Performances & Results

March 3rd, 2010 | 19 komentar
Kategori: American Idol

Photobucket
1. Michael Lynche – “This Is A Man’s Man’s World” by James Brown
RJ: I feel like right now this season is starting to get rolling. Dawg I have got to give it to you. R&B star.
ED: I have liked everyone song choice so far. That was the one to beat. The way to start off the night.
KD: I did not get it until tonight. You went from being a singer to someone who could be a great artist. I am feeling it.
SC: From a pussycat to a lion in one week. The right kind of song for you. It suited you and it didn’t sound dated. Your best performance in the competition.
CD: Michael tampil beda! Kali ini dengan gaya soulful yang emang menonjolkan vocalnya, bener2 emotional! (7/10)

Photobucket
2. John Park – “Gravity” by John Mayer
RJ: That was your vibe but you didn’t bring anything new to it. It was flat and there was some pitch problems.
ED: It was the right song choice. You got into it more than in rehearsal. Feel the song a tiny bit more.
KD: Way better than last week. I lack the connection with you. I don’t always believe it. You need to let loose. You are a little bit safe.
SC: I think Purple Haze may get their lead singer back this week. I struggle with the believability. In 20 minutes time we will forget that performance.
CD: Ouch! What’s wrong with John Park? Dia nyanyi kayak karaoke-an aja… sayang banget. (5/10)
Photobucket
3. Casey James – “I Don’t Want To Be” by Gavin DeGraw
RJ: I love you channeling like Hendrix. I don’t know if you did the best vocal but this is the type of record I would make with you.
ED: You can’t go wrong with the song. I love your look and I love you sound. You need to move more on the stage. I want you to perform more.
KD: The cougar is a fan but tonight you took 2 steps backwards. The notes were off on the bottom and you didn’t take the song to another level. Still a fan though.
SC: I am kind of with Kara. This week you turned into someone you would see in any bar in America. You don’t have the grit in your voice to make that work.
CD: Who can beat Elliot Yamin version of this song? Bo bice, Chris Richardson pun juga sudah bawain ini… tapi Casey James tidak bisa bawain lebih baik.. standard. Tapi dia berhasil nunjukin kalo dia jago main gitar.. (6/10)

Photobucket
4. Alex Lambert – “Everybody Knows” by John Legend
RJ: Such an improvement over last week. You found your own niche a little bit. Way legit tonight.
ED: Someone took the unripe banana and put it in a paper bag. So much better than last week. You have such a great voice. You have a unique style.
KD: You have an incredible recording tone. You will learn how to use it. Great improvement.
SC: That was a million times better than last week. You should only be nervous if you are useless and you are not.
CD: Wow! Great improvement! Bawa gitar dan tampil keren banget! Best performance so far! (8/10)

Photobucket
5. Todrick Hall – “What’s Love Got To Do With It” by Tina Turner
Judges Thoughts : (R) The falsetto run at the end was hot. I didn’t love this. Sing a nice song and just sing it. (E) Sing and move. Use your strength, your a dancer. I don’t think it was the right song. That song didn’t help you get any votes. (K) We all like you. When you started moving, it got better. I don’t get it, what happened to Todrick. (S) Todrick, move but don’t sing. This is not working out at all for you.
CD: Hmm.. kenapa selalu pilih lagu cewek yah? Sayangnya, penampilannya gak asik nih. (5/10)

Photobucket
6. Jermaine Sellers “What’s Going On” by Marvin Gaye
(R) Better than last week. It was so close but so far. It just wasn’t a great performance. Another tough song to sing. You needed to pull it back more. (E) I love your style but it just didn’t work for me. You pushed to hard again. (K) You are hitting some crazy notes but you are doing to much. Pull back and look for the meaning of the song. It feels forced. (S) We’re frustrated. You water down the songs. No one can take you seriously as an artist.
CD: Pilihan lagunya yang susah! What’s going on with Jermaine? Mestinya dia bisa pilih lagu yang lebih modern dan bawain lebih bagus daripada ini. (6/10)

Photobucket
7. Andrew Garcia – “You Give Me Something” by James Morrison
(R) Honestly, that wasn’t the vibe for you. It was pitchy all over the place. I didn’t get it. (E) I thought there were a couple of little pitch problems but I liked it. I am still a huge fan and I thought you were really good. (K) Since your Paula song it has been straight down. You have to surprise us. You played it too safe. We need another big surprise. (S) You are lacking something. Not choosing the right song again is a problem. It was just ok and you are better than ok.
CD: Err.. Sayang banget penampilan Andrew Garcia kayak karaoke-an juga nih, gak bawa sesuatu yang baru di lagu ini. (6/10)

Photobucket
8. Aaron Kelly – “My Girl” by The Temptations
(R) I didn’t know if I was going to like this. Dude you can really sing. That was 200% better than last week. (E) A whole lot more confidence. You sing well but the song is a bit forgettable. You do have a great voice. (K) I really liked it and I like you. You are consistent. You have control. You are doing better and better. (S) I didn’t like the song. It was all over the place. You went backwards. You have to work out what kind of artist you want to be. The arrangement was too old fashioned.
CD: Umurnya gak beda2 jauh dengan Justin Bieber.. tapi kenapa pilihan lagunya tua2 yah… tapi kayaknya masih bertahan terus nih karena banyak fansnya. (6/10)

Photobucket
9. Tim Urban – “Come On Get Higher” by Matt Nathanson
Judges Thoughts : (R) I didn’t get it. It was very karaoke for me. Some pitch problems, nothing jumped out. (E) You should act. You should be on Glee. Girls would love you. If you act, yo have it made. (K) I liked the song choice but you didn’t make it your own. You look the part, you play the part but it’s not all there yet. (S) I think that was a much improvement from last week. You picked a young song. You were more relevant than the other singers. I am impressed with your performance, your attitude and work ethic.
CD: Gak ada kemajuan dari minggu lalu, cuman nilai plusnya hanya dia bawa gitar ajah.. (6/10)

Photobucket
10. Lee DeWyze – “Lips Of An Angel” by Hinder
(R) Bold Move. I liked it. I am a huge fan of yours. A couple of pitch problems but I liked it. (E) A couple of little pitch problems but it didn’t matter cause it came out as a great performance. It was great. (K) I thought it was a big improvement from last week. Some pitch problems still this week but I could hear you on the radio. Your look is commercial. (S) Raise your shoulders. Vocally you are head and shoulders above everyone else. You may be the one to beat.
CD: Lee bener menunjukkan kalo dia jadi ‘kuda hitam’ di group cowok! Good! (7/10)

Siapa yang bakal pulang besok? Pilihan CD jatuh pada Todrick Hall dan John Park!

ELIMINATED: John Park & Jermaine Sellers!

19 Responses to “American Idol 9 Top 10 Boys Performances & Results”

  1. andy_blui says:
    March 3, 2010 at 8:11 pm

    kyx yg kluar si jermaine n john…

  2. Musicoholic says:
    March 4, 2010 at 6:49 am

    —CD: Umurnya gak beda2 jauh dengan Justin Bieber.. tapi kenapa pilihan lagunya tua2 yah… tapi kayaknya masih bertahan terus nih karena banyak fansnya.—

    Welly,

    “lagu tua” dia luar itu laen sama lagu di sini. Lagu tua di sana (amongst hundreds of thousand other songs) contohnya kayak My Girl ini udah jadi international ‘classics’/’standards’. Lo memberi kesan bahwa “lagu tua” itu adalah lagu usang yang ngga layak dinyanyikan anak muda.
    Yang jadi masalah itu kan bukan kapan muncul lagu itu, yg bisa bikin problem ya arrangementnya dan cara bawainnya.
    Kalo lo ga dikasih tau lagu it’s a man’s man world lagu JB juga jangan2 lo ga tau itu ‘lagu tua’. Lynche juga umurnya 26, dia nyanyiin lagu dari tahun 1966 (kalo My girl kira2 taun 64-65). Dan kontestan ini pasti akan nyanyiin “lagu tua” itu udah dari season 1, karena ada minggu bertema spesifik. Some of the greatest performances di Idol pun “lagu tua” (say….Fantasia’s summertime, atau Adam’s Track of my tears, atau performances by creativedisc boytoy David Archu Imagine or Love Me Tender )

    Dan di music scene yang ada sekarang ini, banyak yang nyanyiin “lagu tua” dan did so well, contohnya aja Michael Buble, dia nyanyiin lebih dari stengah albumya lagu dari tahun 30an, 40an dan 50an, would you say itu “lagu tua” ????

  3. Adam Fachry says:
    March 4, 2010 at 7:14 am

    Gue malah senang kalo para kontestan itu milih “lagu2 tua”. Apalagi kalo lagu2 itu belum gitu familiar di gue, atau bukan termasuk yang sudah dilabeli classic/standard. Bisa menambah knowledge gue soalnya. Lagipula, lagu2 mainstream current, range style dan genrenya juga nggak begitu luas2 amat. Beberapa kontestan mungkin juga nggak suit sama kumpulan genre yang ada masa kini.

    Mas welly udah yakin kalo aaron nyanyi “lagu muda” bakalan kasih performance yang outstanding ? kan ga ada jaminan juga kan? Semuanya kembali ke cara si kontestan itu membawakannya dan menginterpretasikannya.

  4. Musicoholic says:
    March 4, 2010 at 7:56 am

    Ga ada jaminan pastinya…..yang bawain “lagu baru” aja kyk John Park dikasih nilai 5 sama Bung Welly

    apa pointnya ? The points are :

    1. bukan soal usia lagunya. Tapi tergantung cara masing-masing kontestan membawakannya aja.

    2. memang ada lagu2 yang udah di recognize sebagai lagu ‘classic’/’standards’/sepanjang masa.

  5. Jhonatan Asyari says:
    March 4, 2010 at 10:20 am

    ——CD: Umurnya gak beda2 jauh dengan Justin Bieber.. tapi kenapa pilihan lagunya tua2 yah… tapi kayaknya masih bertahan terus nih karena banyak fansnya. (6/10)——

    hmm,,,bener banget apa yang dibilang MUSICOHOLIC, nothings wrong the old song?menurut gw itu klasik, dan generasi muda kalau membawakannya dengan outstanding hasilnya akan jauh dari kesan TUA??emang harus yah umur2 beiber kudu nyanyi kayak chris brown…masukan aja buat CD don’t be so subjective…toh yang digadang-gadang bakal keluar juga sering meleset..still remember connie talbot bawain “ben” terus tu little angel dibilang TUA juga dong pilihan lagunya padahal performancenya bikin juri menangis…just remember music is like colour…penuh perbedaan tapi kaya akan harmonisasi…oke,,,maju terus CD

  6. zul says:
    March 4, 2010 at 10:58 am

    my fav performance minggu ini ALEX LAMBERT!!..suaranya enak banget buat didengerin..bener banget kata Kara suaranya alex recordable..mg2 safe dan minggu depan bisa lebih bagus lagi..

    prediksi yang bakal out..
    Jermaine, boring!!..ga suka juga sama attitude dia yang sok yakin bkal safe minggu ini..HARUS OUT!!!
    yang kedua, antara John Park/Todrick..lagu gravitynya john mayer jadi kliatan ga da soulnya pdhl ni lagu bgus banget..trus kalo si toddrick lagi2 bkin aransemen yang ga enak..

  7. Musicoholic says:
    March 4, 2010 at 11:46 am

    Kris allen sepanjang idol itu cuma 3x nyanyiin ‘lagu muda’ loh, heartless,apologize dan falling slowly. Sisanya ‘lagu tua’, dan ada lagu CEWEK pula, lagu donna summer taun 83, she works hard for the money. David cook 3x nyanyiin lagu cewe dan ‘tua’. Mereka bisa menang idol loh. Pls jgn underrate ‘lagu tua’. Back ke mgg ini, aduh kyknya todrick ini mesti pergi, awal nyanyi rada bisa diterima. Setengah lagu ke belakang ancur.

  8. welly says:
    March 4, 2010 at 11:48 am

    thanks buat masukannya.
    anyway, gw pribadi suka ama vocal john park, tapi kemarin bawain ‘gravity’ nya jelek banget.. dan kayaknya dia yang bakal out besok. hehe cuman prediksi aja

  9. winda says:
    March 4, 2010 at 1:14 pm

    dukung Alex Lambert deh :)
    meskipun powernya masih dbawah yg laen tapi suaranya punya keunikan tersendiri.
    Casey nyanyinya kalah banget kalo dbandingin I dont want to be versi Bo Bice dan Elliot Yamin
    Lee juga biasa aja, Andrew ngecewain trs, bisa2 dia out kalo gini trs,TIDAK!!
    yg lain boring..
    Aaron serasa dengerin matt giraud nyanyi tapi dengan powerless ala chris richardson, just imo

  10. aryo says:
    March 4, 2010 at 1:16 pm

    lagu tuwa malah bisa jadi nilai plus buat yang ngebawain.. tergantung

    1. jenis lagunya sesuai dengan karakter yang ngebawain..
    2. terdengar lebih fresh dan kini… namun ga merubah isi yang ingin di sampein dalam lagunya,,,

    jd ga masalah jika lagu tuwa di bawain…

    lagian penampilan aaron juga lumayan ngebawain lagu tuwa…

    lagu kini “Come On Get Higher” by Matt Nathanson aja malah amburadul pas d bawain tim…

    jd permasalahannya bukan pada lagunya… tapi tergantung gimana orang yang membawakannya dan gimana hasilnya……

    @zul: cara narik nafas dalam bernyanyi nya si alex lambert mirip dengan matt giraud.. unik..

    i hope tim urban out..
    bersama john

    atau casey… coz.. pendahulunya sudah banyak yang ngebawain nie lagu… tp versi dia ga kalah payahnya dengan versinya michael sarver..
    sebenarnya suaranya cukup bagus.. asalkan pilihan lagunya tepat…

  11. ira says:
    March 4, 2010 at 9:22 pm

    Lagu tua di barat itu melegenda, jadi generasi muda juga pada familiar sama lagu lagu itu…yg bkal out kayanya jermaine…

    Gue mulai ngrasa annoyed dengan juri2 yg trus2an ‘pimping’ salah satu kontestan, slain rada2 ga fair, itu juga bisa jadi ‘beban’ buat kontestan yang di’pimp’

  12. aduy says:
    March 5, 2010 at 8:08 am

    @winda haha akhirnya mbak winda dukung lambrt lagiii hehehe kayak amboo

  13. winda says:
    March 5, 2010 at 8:39 am

    @aduy; iya,habis liat Everybody Knows jadi suka,,he..he.. soalnya yg laen boring n dia termasuk beda sendiri, great performance..
    dukung another lambert lagi deh taun ini :)

  14. muj says:
    March 5, 2010 at 9:33 am

    terserah sech pada jagoin sapa, karena saya gak bisa liat, arrgghhh *menunggu sajah*

  15. Aoh says:
    March 5, 2010 at 9:37 am

    Aduh…. I’ve lost another sweetheart this week…. huhuhuhu… *nanges darah untuk John Park*

  16. Jhonatan Asyari says:
    March 5, 2010 at 9:39 am

    aku jagoin Alex Lambert Ah

  17. Gun_guN says:
    March 5, 2010 at 4:06 pm

    go Lambert go….

  18. aduy says:
    March 5, 2010 at 5:03 pm

    hehe go lambert go :P I still think that the winner this year is gonna be a guy.. because i’m also a guy..

  19. Rony says:
    March 5, 2010 at 6:34 pm

    I like ALEX LAMBERT…

    SUMPAHHHHHH!!

    kereeeen

Leave a Reply

go to top